10 comments so far
Good points, however you left out a key part. What actions would you suggest for the administration to follow? That’s the hard part. Nothing seems to be working. lol Maybe the EU could issue an ultimatum to Iran!?
The EU works as a broker and as a host of talks in this issue…
http://www.neurope.eu/articles/EU-helps-broker-Iran-okay-on-nuclear-inspections-deal/96667.php
http://www.google.com/hostednews/ap/article/ALeqM5j_AjvoxouJkUXONQ6eH_cMii4CZwD9ASIR7O2
And what pray tell would the EU do if Iran refuses to cooperate?
Or more to the point what COULD the EU do if Iran refuses to cooperate?
The EU being a host of the talks is a far cry from actually doing anything to solve the problem. Hey this is pretty cool.
By the way, thank you Lear for surrendering the playing field of ideas to me! By not offering any opinions I get to demonstrate the relative impotence of the EU without any dissenting thoughts.
The EU is a demonstrably powerful economic player, only following the US, China, and maybe India, but since it does little else it doesn’t belong in the top 10.
I have also been thinking about the top 10. Professor Frost, shouldn’t India be moving up the scale because of its economic prowess that goes along with its military power?
Let me guess, micci,
you´ve been the annoying clown at school.
And at the moment everybody was pissed of your attention seeking provocations you kept going, right ?
Well Lear, I probably was annoying at school, being the person in charge means your employees want you to give them raises each and every year. But since I retired a number of years ago they have nothing but good feelings about me. lol
It still doesn’t change the fact that the EU is not a major player on the world political scene, except in economics. I’ll give you that.
Besides I thought you weren’t going to respond to my thoughts any longer.
And if you could give me lucid arguments (not merely references you pull of the internet) I might actually reconsider your position.
So answer one question. Could and would the EU take military action if one of its member countries were to suffer a major terrorist attack?
You still are asking the wrong questions !
I´m sorry to repeat it, it sounds like the schoolboy who wants to know which of the
schoolmates can fart the loudest.
The question in a globalized interdependent world is what multiple measures of power holds the EU as singular entity or as combined entity of nations with the same interests and potential of resources.
Europe: The Quiet Superpower
http://209.85.135.132/search?q=cache:uO6Ia7MN6fcJ:www.princeton.edu/~amoravcs/library/french_politics.docx+%22Europe%27s+rise%22+%22great+power%22&cd=1&hl=en&ct=clnk&gl=de
I don’t believe I am asking the wrong question. Actually, by refusing to even answer the question you give the impression that the EU is not the power that you claim it to be. Major powers do not get to choose the questions with which they deal and the terrorist situation is one that every major power must address. If the EU cannot deal with a major terrorist attack, how can they be taken seriously as a major world power?
By attempting what you perceive as insults you debase your own position. In your last two comments you have descended to personal attacks rather than just answering based on your own knowledge. This makes the average reader question whether or not you can answer the questions. I will give you the benefit of the doubt and assume that if you chose to do so you could make some kind of answer. And I would very much like to hear a cogent EU plan in that area, not some click on reference as you often do, but a plan spelled out that the average person can understand.
If the EU cannot address something like a terrorist threat with some credible plan of action then the EU is not a world power as individual nations are.
The EU has tremendous influence in the economic sphere, and if you limit the definition of a world power strictly to that sphere then they would have to be considered in the top ten. But it appears to me that this exercise includes far more than economics.
Interesting. I did go to the link that Lear posted:
and read it thoroughly.
I was obvious that the writer was a great supporter of the EU and he made many salient points. He did however point out that the EU is a “civilian power” as opposed to a great national power. I can only suppose that by qualifying the EU’s influence in such a manner that he is admitting that when it comes right down to it the EU can do little but talk.
So in retrospect, I am willing to concede that the EU is one of the 10 great “civilian” powers. Of course now we also have to consider Microsoft as a pretty great civilian power. lol

USA
China
Russia
Japan
Germany
India
Brazil
France
UK
Turkey


mytradewiki.com…
[...]Iran-US Nuclear Talks: Our Leverage is Leaking | Great Power Politics[...]…
We wholesale all types of fine sexy lingerie, such as: Adult costumes, corsets, chemises, babydolls, bikini sets, sexy ladies’ panties, men’s panties, sexy garter sets, erotic dresses, sexy stockings and sexy leather collections. The annual output …
[...]Great Power Politics » Blog Archive » Iran-US Nuclear Talks: Our Leverage is Leaking[...]…
bespoke access database design…
[...]Great Power Politics » Blog Archive » Iran-US Nuclear Talks: Our Leverage is Leaking[...]…